Monday, June 30, 2014

School Violence

I've been trying to publish this for several weeks. I'm struggling with my own thoughts and my own process of these events, and I don't yet feel I have done them justice. But, I think I just need to hit publish and stop questioning myself. I have tried to avoid bias and assumptions, and I could be wrong, but I still want to examine a few things.

-----------------------

My older son graduated from high school about three weeks ago. My younger son will begin attending this same school in the fall.

The seniors finished classes on June 5th, with graduation being on June 12th. On June 10th, the rest of the school, some 2000 students and staff, experienced something communities have learned to fear: a student's act of gun violence on campus. As a result, our community lost two young men; one was the victim, one was the perpetrator. These young men seemed to have all the promise in the world; good kids, good students, good sons. Two sons went off to school, like any other day, on the second-to-last day of classes for the 2013-2014 school year. Sons who were expected to return home at the end of the school day, but who never again will. Our community grieves, deeply.

Of course, much conversation surrounds these events. We hear questions posed by the media such as these: How did the young man gain access to the weapon? Why did no one know he was in this frame of mind? What can we do in the future to prevent this type of event? Gun control? School security? Holding family members responsible when children access their weapons?

I'm no expert and I don't propose any solutions. However, based on the continued prevalence of school shootings, it would seem that we (as a society) haven't yet found the right combination of steps to effectively prevent them.

I can't help but wonder if more prevention and intervention at the school level could help. I'm not just guessing in the dark, either. A recent article by the NASW (National Association of Social Workers) shares this concern:
"Headlines announcing the latest incidents of school violence have become common, and calls for solutions have been open to debate. Rather than promote a fortress mentality to protect students from violence, social workers are urging more programs and resources that provide early mental health screenings and treatments for school children. In addition, social workers are promoting the value of a community approach to aid troubled students before they feel the need to act out in violence."
The 2002 U.S. Secret Service Safe Schools Initiative reports that nearly 75% of perpetrators of school violence experienced acts of bullying or exclusion by peers, and over 75% had a history of suicidal thoughts, actions, or experience of depression. Having been 12 years since this report, a cursory examination of school violence since could indicate a similar trend.

In other words, I don't believe school violence happens in a vacuum.

I think school counseling staff members have a unique position in this process. They are on the front lines of the things their students struggle with; academically, but also socially, mentally, and emotionally. Yet, so many schools lack adequate counseling staff to be effective in this area. In the case of our school, an eight member counseling staff serves some 2400+ students. We have only one social worker among them.

Of course, I also don't suggest it is only the counseling staff members' responsibility; after all, students also have teachers, families, social groups, sports groups, spiritual or religious groups, friends, jobs...there are any number of people who may be able to spot potential trouble. But, there is evidently a need for more school staff members who are trained in counseling to identify and intervene in problematic issues. When there are too few counselors, this is difficult.

It's not my intention to place blame. Staffing shortages in public schools are such an enormous, systemic problem in our educational system that it would be unfair to blame any one person, group, school, district, or government entity. It's simply an observation that the current system may need to change.

I have no way to know whether or not any relationship with a school counselor existed or could have prevented this specific act of violence at my son's school. I just wonder if, in general, more school counselors and social workers would reduce the risk of these types of acts of violence. I know that's impossible to quantify, but I can't help but be thoughtful about it.

Unfortunately, in the wake of school violence, odds are more money will be spent to upgrade security measures at this school than will be spent in the areas of increasing staffing for earlier identification and prevention of the types of issues that may lead to school violence. I do think it has to be holistic; yes, maybe more active protection of students is necessary, but also more staff who are trained in identifying potential trouble, and who may know how to take steps to intervene.

I don't know the solution, if there even is one. I think there are a variety of steps that could be taken to help reduce these incidents. I don't know how to implement those steps, or who to charge with that process. I do think an increase in school counseling staff and a greater importance placed on early identification and intervention could help. I understand many school districts would have to rethink their budgets for this to happen, and I readily admit that I don't know where the money ought to come from.

I just know that, for a few hours one Tuesday morning two weeks ago, thousands of parents in our community waited to hear whether or not their teenagers were safe. Two families would learn their sons were not. Our community lost two youth, and we deeply grieve for their families and friends.

I also know that it's impossible to say whether or not any changes have taken place in recent decades have succeeded at prevention. We can't know if more acts of violence have been prevented than have occurred. I don't know that we can ever fully eliminate this type of event.

I do believe we still ought to be thinking about it. Is a ratio of 300/1 students to counseling staff members effective enough?

*** Update: I did some further research. According to the American School Counselor Association, they recommend a ratio of 250:1, but most states have their own guidelines or mandates.
Oregon does not have any counselor to student ratio mandates.
Oregon's statewide 2010-2011 ratio was 533:1.
Oregon Administrative Rule 581-022 recommends compliance with the ASCA.

Wednesday, June 4, 2014

Advocating for Education

I had the opportunity today to advocate for a student; a senior in high school who is due to graduate next week. This student had been identified as experiencing a learning disability and, as a result, had some academic struggles in previous years of high school. However, this student was quite determined to graduate with their cohort.

This student worked diligently all year, and successfully completed everything necessary to graduate on time. However, two weeks prior to graduation, the student was informed that, through no fault of their own, they would not be able to graduate.

I wish I didn't need to be so vague, but I have to protect privacy. Let's call it "administrative error". It was quite unjust; something that *should* have been prevented through a series of checks and balances that did not occur.

This is not my area of expertise (do I even have one?), but it is an area where I happen to have some experience. I understand the relevant policies, and I understand the student's rights.

As a family friend, I was invited to attend a meeting with an administrator, several school staff members, this student, and their parent. I brought federal, state and district level policy that applied to this situation, along with other relevant documentation. The conversation began with, "There's nothing we can do." Once the facts were presented and it became clear that I was familiar with the student's rights, the conversation ended with the administrator taking this situation directly to the district level, and the problem was resolved in three hours.

Later, the administrator thanked me for advocating for the student. I was told, "It made all the difference." Although this situation was unique, I couldn't help but wonder about other students who have experienced some type of "administrative error", but do not have a parent or friend who is able to advocate for their rights.

It would seem that school counselors, case managers, social workers, heck, even teachers ought to be doing the advocating. However, in a high-poverty school where each counseling staff member may be responsible for up to 400 students, what do we expect to happen?

I am not prepared to argue issues of school funding; it's too complex.

However, I do know funding is a serious problem at the micro level, where students aren't being served appropriately because a school just doesn't have the funding to ensure students are being served appropriately. It then becomes the student's, the parent's, the family friend's, problem to advocate for the student.

The state of Oregon has recently enacted a goal to have a 100% high school graduation rate by the year 2025. I know our local high school's current graduation rate is somewhere around 60%. So, how is this goal going to be met?

I don't present any solutions. I only know I was grateful for the opportunity to be at this meeting, aiding in resolution.

For this one student.

What about that student? And that one?

Tuesday, May 27, 2014

#YesAllWomen

Repost of items posted to my Fb page: Paraphrases of Tweets from the #YesAllWomen feed and my reactions to this activism.

We all should be following #YesAllWomen.
THIS is why Santa Barbara happened.
This hashtag is the most amazing, powerful, strong, united vibrant, anti-rape-culture thing I've ever read. Ever.
Because "Women are not objects".
Because "Women's default position is not 'sexual partner'".
Because "My hormones make me an ineffective leader, but a man's hormones absolve him of rape".
Because "It's safer to give a man a fake phone number" or to "tell him I have a boyfriend" "than to just turn him down".
And, "If you're offended, you're the problem".

Because "I have to think about my risk every time I leave the house: what I'm wearing, what time it is, and where the safe places are along the way."
Because "#NotAllMen are creeps, but if I don't know you, I have no way of telling the difference."
Because "I teach my sons that the word 'No' is the end of a conversation, not the beginning of a bargaining session."
Because "Women have internalized objectification: we judge other women's level of risk based on what they are wearing."
Because "Not enough men will intervene when I'm experiencing street harassment."
Because "If you don't understand, YOU are the problem."
#YesAllWomen

Because "Power isn't a zero-sum game." #YesAllWomen

Because "Feminism is about equity, not superiority."
Because "Women candidates like Hillary are judged more for their appearance than their ability to lead."
Because "Sexism and misogyny are forms of structural violence."

Yes, I believe in this, passionately and unapologetically. It's about time the voices were heard. I'm perfectly willing to have the difficult conversations. But, if you don't like it, hide me or unfriend me. #YesAllWomen

Because "Some men believe women shouldn't not have ultimate autonomy over their bodies - appearance, sexuality, reproduction."
#YesAllWomen

If you are male and don't understand what women are so angry about, I challenge you to spend 30 minutes reading #YesAllWomen.

Because, YES, every single one of us has experienced unwanted objectification, catcalls and street harassment, being groped (often by strangers). Most of us have experienced unwanted sexual advances. Far, far too many women have been assaulted or raped.

This problem is created by a culture that teaches men that they have the right to access women's bodies: women they don't even know, women they see on a street or meet in a social setting, women they have taken on a date or bought dinner for, women they in a committed relationship with. Women are NEVER "asking for" unwanted objectification, touching, or advances, and men NEVER "deserve" any access to a woman's body.

This same culture teaches men that "No" means "Maybe", and "Maybe" means "Yes". And this same culture says men ought to have the right to pass laws that limit what a woman can or can't do with her own body. It's all the same culture, and it needs to change. Women are NOT here to be the object of or to be controlled by men's desires. #YesAllWomen

If you are the father of a son, teach him that women are not objects. If you are the father of a daughter, teach other men that women like your daughter are not objects. Men, if you don't like what women have to say about this, you have power to change the culture so we can stop saying it. Start today. If you don't understand, I challenge you to spend 30 minutes following#YesAllWomen.

Tuesday, May 20, 2014

Victory!

I want to begin this blog with a celebration of sorts.

I can remember in the early 1990s Oregon Ballot Measure 9. In this measure, some Oregonians sought to add the following provision to the Oregon Constitution:
"All governments in Oregon may not use their monies or properties to promote, encourage or facilitate homosexuality, pedophilia, sadism or masochism. All levels of government, including public education systems, must assist in setting a standard for Oregon's youth which recognizes that these behaviors are abnormal, wrong, unnatural and perverse and they are to be discouraged and avoided."
This ballot measure failed, but it left a lingering stink in Oregon.

In 2004, our county began issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples. However, this step didn't follow proper "procedures". These licenses were invalidated and and this process was discontinued.

In late 2004, Oregonians passed an amendment defining marriage as one man/one woman. Margin was 57/43. It was a dark day.

This stood for nearly 10 years.

Yesterday, a Federal judge overturned the 2004 ban, and same sex couples began marrying immediately. A stay was denied.

Today, we have marriage equality in Oregon, and I couldn't be prouder of my state. I have friends, peers, and other associates who are positively impacted by this ruling, and I'm thrilled they will now have the option of marrying their partners, if and when they wish.

Anyhow, it's not "gay marriage" or "same sex marriage".

It's just MARRIAGE.

Equality is not complete, but I will spend today basking in the joy of this huge step we've taken. There will be a new fight for tomorrow.